15-Minute Cities: Utopia or Dystopia?

What is a 15 minute city?

Imagine a morning where you can stroll through the park with your kids, drop them at school, then head to work—all within 15 minutes from your front door. This is the promise of the 15-minute city, where daily life revolves around community and accessibility, not traffic jams and long commutes. But is this idyllic vision of urban living a reality, or is it just a utopian dream?

The concept of 15-minute cities aims to create compact, efficient urban areas where residents can access everything they need for daily life within a 15-minute walk or bike ride from their homes. This includes work, education, healthcare, leisure, and shopping. While the concept might seem modern, it has roots in past urban planning theories, such as 'neighbourhood units' proposed by Clarence Perry in the 1920s and the 'new urbanism' movement of the 1980s.

The Triple Pillar Benefits

Designing cities to be more accessible and compact brings numerous benefits across the social, environmental, and economic spheres—the three pillars of sustainable development.

Social Benefits

With the average American commute time at about 27 minutes, halving this would free up precious time for exercise, family, or even an extra bit of sleep! It promotes healthier lifestyles by encouraging walking or cycling and promises cleaner air by reducing vehicle emissions that create air pollution*. Additionally, the 15-minute city model can enhance community bonds and mental health by reducing isolation, particularly among the elderly.

Environmental Impact

Reducing the reliance on cars and buses to get around not only cuts down on air pollution but also contributes significantly to combating climate change. As we inch closer to the critical 1.5°C global warming limit, innovative urban planning like 15-minute cities could be a crucial element in global climate strategies. 

Economic Upsides

There are untold economic advantages, from lessening the strain on public transport to revitalizing underused spaces. Imagine a community hall that doubles as a co-working space by day to an event center on the weekend as well as the activities it hosts currently (which tend to mainly be in the evening on weekdays). This efficient use of infrastructure can spark local economic growth, innovation and contribute to building a greater sense of community. 

Real-World Examples

Paris, under Mayor Anne Hidalgo, is actively pursuing the 15-minute city vision. Read this article from NPR for an insight into how Paris is embracing the idea of being a 15 minute city. 

But, Paris is not alone in these efforts; cities like Barcelona, Melbourne, Buenos Aires, Bogotá, and Portland are exploring similar concepts. These efforts showcase the practicality and appeal of creating more livable, sustainable urban environments.

*Air pollution is a major environmental and health issue, contributing to one in ten deaths globally. 

Why Didn’t We Stick With This Idea?

The idea of living close to everything isn't groundbreaking. Historically, towns and cities inherently had all essentials within close reach. That is until, the widespread adoption of cars and public transport systems began stretching the fabric of our cities, leading to the urban sprawl we see today. Car and multi-car ownership has increased exponentially across the globe since they became commonplace in the early 20th century. 

While transport advancements have undoubtedly improved our lives by connecting us to places and opportunities that were not accessible before, they've also tied us to a reliance on vehicles. This dependence has its downsides, from exacerbating urban sprawl to contributing significantly to environmental pollution. Our city centers, often congested with cars, lose out on the chance to be vibrant community hubs for people, not just passageways for vehicles.

Some cities such as Oslo, Ghent and Paris are now reversing this trend by discouraging driving and in some cases banning cars in central areas to reclaim these spaces for community interaction and environmental benefits.

This shift back to the concept of 15-minute cities isn't about restricting movement but rediscovering a balance where technology serves us without sidelining our health, environment, or community fabric.

Detractors of the model

Despite the clear advantages, transitioning to 15-minute cities faces skepticism and outright opposition from some quarters. Conspiracy theorists have misconstrued the idea as a ploy for excessive governmental control. This fear may come from the trauma of lockdown experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic. They believe governments are introducing this concept to keep people within a 15 minute boundary and they won’t be able to leave without permission. This misleading agenda has not been helped by Jordan Peterson and Joe Rogan showing skepticism to the concept on Rogan’s podcast.

However, it is crucial to demystify these claims, emphasizing that the 15-minute city model aims to enhance, not limit, our quality of life by making daily necessities more accessible and communities more livable.

For more information on how this misleading message has spread - CNN have covered it in detail HERE.

Your Thoughts?

We'd love to hear from you. Are you in favor of the 15-minute city concept? Better yet, do you live in one? Share your experiences and whether this model has impacted your life for the better.

Reach out to us @ [email protected] 

Further Reading

For those who enjoyed learning about 15 minute cities, here are some great articles and podcasts covering the topic in more detail:

• NPR’s Take on 15-Minute Cities as a Climate Solution

• Bloomberg’s Examination of the Controversy

• Deloitte’s Perspective on the Urban Future

• The David McWilliams Podcast on the 15-Minute City

What else is happening in the world of tech?

Alphabet approves its first ever dividend. The parent company announced the 20 cents a share dividend during a positive quarterly earnings call last week.

Do you have about 10,000 unread emails on gmail like me? Here are some tips on how to trim down your overflowing inbox.

AIphone? Apple and OpenAI are back in discussions around a partnership that will bring AI features to iPhones later this year.